Compare medicines · Pain and fever

Tylenol vs Advil: which should you take?

Tylenol (acetaminophen) and Advil (ibuprofen) both relieve pain and fever, but they work differently and have different risks.

Pharmacist reviewed

Tylenol vs Advil: the short answer

Both work well for headaches, fever and everyday aches. Advil also reduces swelling (inflammation), so it often works better for sprains, dental pain and menstrual cramps. Tylenol is gentler on the stomach and is often the safer choice for people with stomach, kidney or heart problems, or who take blood thinners.

Tylenol vs Advil comparison chart

TylenolAdvil
MedicineAcetaminophenIbuprofen (an NSAID)
Relieves pain and feverYesYes
Reduces swellingNoYes
Usual adult dose500 to 1,000 mg every 4 to 6 hours200 to 400 mg every 4 to 6 hours
Adult daily maximum (without a doctor’s advice)4,000 mg in 24 hours1,200 mg in 24 hours
Stomach upset or bleedingRarePossible, especially with regular use
Main safety concernLiver damage if you take too much or drink a lot of alcoholStomach bleeding, kidney problems, higher blood pressure
Take with food?Not neededYes, to protect your stomach

When Tylenol may be the better choice

  • You have had a stomach ulcer or stomach bleeding
  • You take a blood thinner such as warfarin or apixaban
  • You have kidney disease, heart failure or high blood pressure
  • You have asthma that gets worse with anti-inflammatory medicines

When Advil may be the better choice

  • Pain with swelling, such as a sprain or strain
  • Menstrual cramps
  • Dental pain
  • Tylenol alone hasn’t been enough

Can you take Tylenol and Advil together?

For most healthy adults, yes. They are different medicines, so taking them together or alternating them for a short time is generally safe and can relieve pain better than either one alone. Keep each one within its own daily limit, and check with your pharmacist first if you have other health conditions or take other medicines.

Watch for hidden doses

Read the labels

Many cold, flu and sleep products contain acetaminophen or ibuprofen. Taking them with Tylenol or Advil can push you over the daily limit. Check the ingredients or ask your pharmacist.

When to get medical help

Get help right away

  • If you or someone else took more than the daily limit of acetaminophen, call Poison Control (1-844-764-7669 in Ontario) or 911, even if you feel fine
  • Black or bloody stools, or vomit that looks like coffee grounds
  • Pain that lasts more than 5 days or fever that lasts more than 3 days: see your doctor

Tylenol vs Advil: common questions

Is Tylenol or Advil better for a headache?

Both work well for most headaches. Choose the one that is safest for you based on your health and other medicines.

Is Tylenol or Advil better for a fever?

Both lower fever well. Tylenol is often preferred if you have stomach or kidney problems. Children’s doses of both are based on weight, so follow the package or ask your pharmacist.

Can children take Advil?

Children’s ibuprofen can be used in babies 6 months and older. Use the children’s product and dose by weight. Acetaminophen can be used at younger ages. Ask your pharmacist if you’re not sure.

Other medicines used for the same condition:

More medicine comparisons

Sources

  • Health Canada Drug Product Database: product monographs
  • Health Canada: Acetaminophen safety (canada.ca)
  • Ontario Poison Centre (ontariopoisoncentre.ca)

This page gives general information only and does not replace advice from your doctor, nurse practitioner or pharmacist. Do not start, stop or change a medicine without talking to your health care team. In an emergency, call 911.